Visit Our Office
422 E Southern Ave Tempe, Arizona 85282

The Role of Police Reports in Personal Injury Cases

In many personal injury cases, evidence is the thing that is going to decide the fate of the injured party. It’s the only deciding factor in most cases. Police reports are the foundation of these cases, supplying essential evidence to support allegations and clear up what happened in an incident. These are important reports prepared by the law enforcement officers in the course of their duties to serve as the other evidence needed in the court of justice, to have a somewhat neutral description of the events.

Establishing the Facts

At the time of the crash, the police officers will obtain information from the both parties involved and the witnesses. Collecting this data now is important, because with time the memory of what we ate during this stressful time can wane, and the specifics of what we did and what it felt like can get a little murky. By documenting such info, police reports provide a concrete chain of events and an objective account of what took place. In this example, officers will indicate the environment, mannerisms, and any visible injuries immediately observed. This thorough statement is valuable to lawyers and insurance companies who put flesh on the skeleton of the event and provides credibility for the plaintiff’s version of what happened.

Supporting Witness Testimonies

Witness testimony is often a major piece of evidence in personal injury cases, but frequently the credibility and accuracy of witness testimonies are called into question. Witnesses can support their claims further by using a police report which was made at or near the time of the events and corresponds to what other witnesses remember. If a police report has witness statements that were made close in time to the events in question, that naturally gives their stories greater credibility. These are simply observations that provide the rest of us with baselines by which to confirm or refute the narratives presented by each side, helping us all get closer to the truth.

Influencing Insurance Settlements

Insurance companies rely heavily on police reports when assessing claims. These reports offer an unbiased perspective, which can significantly influence the decision-making process regarding settlements. An insurance adjuster reviews the police report to determine liability and evaluate the extent of damages. A well-documented report that clearly outlines fault and damages can expedite the settlement process, leading to a more favorable outcome for the injured party. Conversely, a vague or incomplete report might complicate negotiations, making it harder to achieve a fair resolution.

Legal Proceedings and Evidence

It is just that police reports are commonly offered in court to affirm the complaints of the victim. This is because such reports are considered by judges and juries to be very reliable since they are official records, and have been compiled by police officers. The information that is shared can support other evidence, like medical records or expert testimony. So while a police report may note that one of the parties was cited for violating a traffic law at the time of the accident, this is very helpful to support a negligence claim. Police reports are just objective in nature, and this adds substantial credibility to the injured party side of the argument, and makes putting together a strong case easier.

Challenges and Limitations

Police reports are great, but certainly not perfect. Errors, or worse, omissions, can happen, potentially impacting the outcome of a personal injury case. It is extremely important to carefully review the police report if you are involved in this type of incident and correct any inaccuracies immediately. If need arose, counsel can correct the wrongs or obtain additional statements. As creepy and bizarre as the interview process would be, the incentive of having a police report to support your personal injury litigation is not worth it.

Personal Injury

*No Cost

  • Exam and Advanced Referrals
  • Physical Assessment & Consultation
  • Attorney referrals if needed
  • Medical managed physical therapy and chiropractic visits
  • We offer non-opioid mail order
  • pharmaceuticals if needed


Police reports: In personal injury cases, police reports are important because they tell what police believed about the incident, an objective and detailed account of events. They prove the facts, corroborate testimonies, affect insurance settlements, authenticate legal proceedings. Only it is not lie proof and the new truth serum is far from water-tight, it is still undeniably helpful in the quest for justice, if only to be used to clean or assist in assuring the bare facts. Ensuring the accuracy and comprehensiveness of these reports can greatly improve the chances in favor of these victims for receiving compensation for their injuries.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *